What's going on
The plural -s (and the he/she -s) has three sounds, and you don't get to choose, the sound before it decides.
Voiceless → a hiss (cats). Voiced → a buzz (dogs). After s, z, sh or ch → a whole extra beat (horses). The sibling of the -ed rule.
What the coaches say

SofiaCats. Dogs. Horses. Same letter on the end, three different sounds. And you never get to pick.

AlexThe sound before it decides. After a quiet ending, like in 'cats', it's a soft hiss.

SofiaAfter a voiced ending, like in 'dogs', it buzzes. Dogz.

AlexAnd after a hissy or buzzy ending, horses, buses, watches, you add a whole extra beat.

SofiaCats, dogs, horses. Finger on your throat, off, on, extra syllable.


